Leader: Drink and disorderly
David Cameron in speeches proudly describes the Conservative Party as being the party of law and order. Yet when Worthing’s Tories were given the chance to support a motion which bolstered law and order in our town they went seriously off-message.and every single Tory declined. As we predicted last week we were not surprised as the motion was put forward by the Liberal Democrats which is the only factor Worthing’s Tories are willing to take into account.
Lib Dem Bob Smytherman moved the motion calling for Worthing Borough Council to make tackling alcohol misuse a priority for Worthing both in the Corporate Plan and the Council Budget 2012-13; to work with other local Councils to introduce a minimum unit pricing for alcohol at a level to deter young drinkers and for Worthing Borough’s Licensing & Control Committee to consider minimum pricing for alcohol at its next meeting. The Tories made no amendment but rejected the motion in its entirety.
The Local Health Profiles for England published in July by the Public Health observatories reported Worthing had 2,501 hospital admissions due to alcohol related harm – over 40% higher than the English average of 1,743 admissions. But it is not only the NHS that has to deal with the consequences of our young people drinking cheap alcohol on Friday and Saturday nights. It is the residents who are frightened to go out, it is the residents that suffer noise and damage to their property and cars and it is the innocent resident bystanders who get hurt when alcohol induced violence breaks out in our pubs and town centre. Last August David Cameron called for a crackdown on stores selling cheap drinks to stop alcohol fuelled disorder leaving town and city centres like “the wild west”. Surely any measure to mitigate this should be welcome to his party of law and order.
Worthing’s Tories argued the price would have little effect on consumption. The consumption argument has been researched by the University of Sheffield – they found that harmful alcohol consumption does indeed reduce more than the general drop with price increases. An increase of 10% in the general price has little effect on moderate, hazardous or harmful consumption but a minumum price of 60p per unit reduces moderate consumption 7%, hazardous consumption 12% and harmful consumption 18%. Conversely Worthing’s Tories have also argued drinkers would find cheaper alternatives like meths and boot polish – we don’t think our young people out on a Friday night would see drinking meths or boot polish as “cool” and an acceptable switch from lager.
Deputy Mayor Tory Charles James made his own disorderly intervention into the debate and showed a total lack of grasp of the law underlying hearings of the Worthing Licensing & Control Committee on which he sits. Cllr James made a personal attack on Bob Smytherman for daring to introduce the motion as Bob had chaired recent licensing sub-committees which had approved applications from off licences where there had been local objection. The Deputy Mayor had failed to appreciate that the Licensing Committee is a quasi-legal body and can only reject applications if they contravene the local licensing rules laid down by Worthing Borough Council in accordance with statutory law and not just because the application is not liked. In fact the motion was an attempt to influence a re-writing of those regulations.
It is not the first time that Cllr James has attempted to cast an unwarranted slur on a Liberal Democrat councillor and not the first time the victim has deserved an unreserved apology – we expect no less this time.
We also expect that Cllr James withdraws from the Licensing Committee until such time as he knows the rules.
Leave a Reply